九一星空无限

ZB ZB
Opinion
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Up next
ZB

Councillor accused of racism for comments on Chinese garden

Author
Melissa Nightingale, NZ Herald,
Publish Date
Fri, 9 Jun 2023, 10:56am
Wellington City councillor Nicola Young said she has apologised and withdrawn the comment. File Photo / Mark Mitchell
Wellington City councillor Nicola Young said she has apologised and withdrawn the comment. File Photo / Mark Mitchell

Councillor accused of racism for comments on Chinese garden

Author
Melissa Nightingale, NZ Herald,
Publish Date
Fri, 9 Jun 2023, 10:56am

A Wellington City councillor has been accused of racism for calling a proposed Chinese garden on the waterfront an 鈥淯yghur鈥檚 park鈥.

The Uyghurs are an ethnic group that have been subjected to human rights abuses by the Chinese government, often characterised as genocide.

Councillor Nicola Young spoke in yesterday鈥檚 committee meeting in support of a Fale Malae being built on Wellington鈥檚 waterfront at Frank Kitt鈥檚 Park.

Having previously been against the proposal because she was reluctant for any more buildings on the waterfront, Young said she had changed her mind, believing it would be an asset to the city.

鈥淚 remain constant and will not change on my opposition to the Ugyhur鈥檚 park, I mean, the Chinese garden,鈥 she added.

Greater Wellington Regional councillor and former city councillor David Lee attended the committee meeting to show his support for the Fale Malae.

Lee, who is Chinese, said he felt proud to hear civic leaders discussing taking steps to be inclusive and recognise Pasifika people.

鈥淭hat feeling of warmth and goodwill rapidly evaporated when I heard the racist comment from Cr Young, who reaffirmed her opposition to the 鈥楿yghur鈥檚 Park, I mean the Chinese Garden鈥,鈥 he said in an email to councillors.

鈥淚n a single, racist and offensive soundbite the councillor belittled a race of people facing genocide, and showed total contempt for the Chinese community,鈥 he said.

He noted his disappointment that nobody called Young out for her remark at the time.

鈥淲ellington City Council is the most diverse and inclusive local government body in New Zealand. Last year, when most cities and districts voted right, Wellington voted left.

鈥淯ntil today, I was confident that the mana of all people, including people of colour, would be upheld in Wellington. I was wrong.

鈥淎s civic leaders, it is your responsibility to call out racism when you see it or hear it. Today, the silence was deafening.鈥

However, Young told 九一星空无限 she had been asked by chairwoman Tamatha Paul to apologise for her comment later in the meeting, which she did immediately.

鈥淚 apologised and withdrew the comment,鈥 she said.

She said the Chinese garden was to be a gift from the local Chinese community, but they had discovered much of the funding was coming from inland China, which was why she had made the comment.

Chinese people were a 鈥渨onderful part鈥 of Wellington鈥檚 community and Young had many friends among them, she said.

She knew of Lee鈥檚 comments.

鈥滵avid knows I鈥檓 not a racist . . . look at my friends, you know?鈥

Speaking to 九一星空无限, Lee said the comment was 鈥渟o inappropriate鈥 and was a 鈥渞eal put down to the Chinese people and the Uyghur people鈥.

鈥淚 found it very offensive.鈥

He said he initially thought nobody had called her out, but now accepted some had but due to technology issues, their comments weren鈥檛 picked up.

鈥淚 was a bit disappointed there wasn鈥檛 a point of order called . . . It wasn鈥檛 actually addressed at the time.

鈥淚 know there was an apology after, but the apology after was not a public thing.鈥

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you