九一星空无限

ZB ZB
Opinion
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Up next
ZB

John MacDonald: Election bribe disguised as a rescue package

Author
John Macdonald ,
Publish Date
Mon, 7 Nov 2022, 12:39pm
Photo / Getty Images
Photo / Getty Images

John MacDonald: Election bribe disguised as a rescue package

Author
John Macdonald ,
Publish Date
Mon, 7 Nov 2022, 12:39pm

If you have teenage children, or if you don鈥檛 have kids, or if you鈥檙e on a pension - chances are you鈥檒l be feeling a bit left out of the Government鈥檚 cost-of-living rescue package.

Yesterday, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern said childcare is one of the most significant costs facing families and said the Government is here to help, and is going to spend an extra $189 million on childcare subsidies.

It won鈥檛 happen overnight - it鈥檒l be spread over four years. Which means, of course, that if you want it - you need to vote for Labour at next year鈥檚 election.

So 鈥榳e鈥檙e coming to your rescue, but only if you vote for us鈥. Which doesn鈥檛 sound like a genuine response to the current crisis does it? Especially when the crisis isn鈥檛 something out there on the horizon, it鈥檚 happening right now and it鈥檚 real for pretty much everyone.

Which is why I鈥檓 saying that if you have teenage children, or if you don鈥檛 have kids, or if you鈥檙e on a pension - you won鈥檛 be feeling much love from the Government right now.

But if even you are someone who stands to benefit from this new spending - if you鈥檙e one of the people the Prime Minister talked about yesterday and you can鈥檛 work simply because childcare is so expensive, well don鈥檛 expect things to change too quickly.

And, for me, it鈥檚 the drawn-out nature of the spending announced yesterday that makes it look like anything but something designed to help with immediate challenges - not to mention the fact that it leaves a whole lot of people no better off.

Prior to yesterday鈥檚 announcement, Jacinda Ardern said the cost-of-living was (quote) 鈥渢op of our agenda鈥, which had commentators speculating that another cost-of-living payment might be on the cards.

You know, the cost-of-living payments - which went to people living overseas and people no longer with us.

So Jacinda Ardern said: "I anticipate that the cost of living and the economy will likely be on everyone's agenda for the next 12 months." And she said it would be at the top of the Government鈥檚 agenda.

That was the talk before yesterday鈥檚 announcement and so, when I compare the talk to what was actually announced, I鈥檝e got to say that I鈥檓 not impressed. For several reasons.

First up - as a parent with three kids, two of whom are still teenagers - there鈥檚 nothing in this announcement for people at my stage in life.

I know childcare is expensive but life is really expensive for families with teenagers. The food bills are huge. The sporting and cultural activities are that much bigger and that much more expensive.

And then what about the people who don鈥檛 have kids at all? Especially those who are single - life鈥檚 pretty expensive for them too. Nothing in this announcement for them.

And then there are our older people. Those on pensions and really struggling to make ends meet, but also the older people who might still be working and still having to support their families - financially or otherwise.

Nothing in this announcement for these people either.

Which is why I think that what the Government announced yesterday is anything but a rescue package to address the current cost-of-living crisis.

Because it鈥檒l be dragged out over three years. It will be dependent on Labour winning next year鈥檚 election. And because so many people are left out and don鈥檛 stand to benefit in any way.

If this is the Government doing what the Prime Minister said it was going to do and put the cost-of-living at the top of its agenda, then I鈥檇 hate to be at the bottom of the agenda if it thinks this is what鈥檚 needed most.

It鈥檚 fine for an election policy. But it fails miserably as a boost for all of the New Zealanders struggling right now to deal with the cost of living.

And I actually think the Government today will be regretting not coming out with something bigger and better, considering that disastrous poll result which came after yesterday afternoon鈥檚 announcement.

I see National leader Christopher Luxon is describing what the Government came out with yesterday as 鈥渂and-aid economics鈥. I actually think he鈥檚 being generous because if it was a band-aid, it would be putting money in people鈥檚 pockets right now - not dragged out over four years and dependent on Labour winning next year鈥檚 election.

I think 鈥渂ribe鈥 is a better description. And not a very generous bribe, at that.

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you