the podcast on
I think we鈥檝e reached peak woke, or at least I hope we have... who would know?
But I think we鈥檝e reached it when I see that in China now, they鈥檙e looking at banning clothes that hurt people鈥檚 feelings. You heard that right.
CNN reported that, 鈥楥hina鈥檚 legislature has proposed changes to a law that if approved would allow authorities to fine and detain people who wear clothes that 鈥渉urt the nation鈥檚 feelings鈥.鈥櫶
This to be honest is probably less about wokeism and more about patriotism and control, and it did of course set off a chain of concerns over freedom of expression. But how on earth do you define clothes that hurt people鈥檚 feelings? I mean I find Crocs offensive, should they ban those? The mom jean I鈥檓 not a big fan of, they鈥檙e everywhere. Jorts... horrific, yet back in fashion. As are wedge jandal heels. I mean it鈥檚 a minefield of offensive clothing out there already as far as I鈥檓 concerned.听
But who are the arbiters of this offensive fashion? Well turns out China鈥檚 National People鈥檚 Congress Standing Committee, wants to ban any garment that is 鈥榙etrimental to the spirit of the Chinese nation.鈥 It鈥檚 a draft amendment proposed for consideration. The proposed amendment's rules would alter the Public Security Administration Punishment Law, 鈥榳hich gives Police power to detain suspects for weeks鈥, or fine them the equivalent of about a thousand NZ dollars. It鈥檚 been up for consultation, and you can just imagine the push back.
CNN reported that, 鈥榮everal legal scholars questioned the implicit vagaries of the proposed amendment, and absence of specific guidelines.鈥 Many called it an overreach. I would have thought the key thing would be a definition of what is construed offensive, and the fact this was missing gives me pause that it will go anywhere. But these days you never know.
China鈥檚 also cracked down on tattoos and 鈥榓rtists with effeminate styles鈥... whatever that means. But you surely can鈥檛 enforce a law as vague as 鈥榦ffensive clothing鈥 without being specific about what that is. One social media user questioned whether suits would be deemed offensive, given they鈥檙e 鈥榯he embodiment of Western Capitalism鈥 as he put it. So, the proposed law, which many have described as 鈥榚xcessive and absurd鈥 could lead to abuse by officials in terms of what constitutes offence. Hence, it鈥檚 problematic.
So a lot of this is obviously about control but the bit that leads me back to whether it鈥檚 wokeism is the fact that it鈥檚 about 鈥榟urt feelings鈥. Hurting feelings 鈥攐r not as the case may be鈥 has become such an acceptable catch phrase it鈥檚 now getting used as an excuse to enforce laws.A couple of months ago people who wore 鈥榬ainbow print clothing were denied entry to a Taiwanese concert in Beijing..鈥 leading one social commentator to ask: 鈥榃hen did the feelings and spirit of the Chinese nation become so fragile?鈥
And it鈥檚 not just China, everywhere seems fragile these days. I鈥檓 with Ricky Gervais, look, when times are weird, we have to turn to the great oracle Ricky Gervais. He famously said, 鈥榟ow arrogant are you, to think you can go through life without anyone ever saying anything you don鈥檛 agree with or like? Just because you鈥檙e offended, doesn鈥檛 mean you鈥檙e right.鈥 He鈥檚 bang on.听
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you
Get the iHeart App
Get more of the radio, music and podcasts you love with the FREE iHeartRadio app. Scan the QR code to download now.
Download from the app stores
Stream unlimited music, thousands of radio stations and podcasts all in one app. iHeartRadio is easy to use and all FREE